Category: Suntec
Suntec – Phillip
Our fundamental view of Suntec REIT has not changed. We feel revenue is still being subjected to pressure as Singapore goes through the recession. We feel key issues for the management will be to maintain the rental while keeping occupancy of the portfolio stable.
Suntec REIT has 64% of its portfolio NLA exposed to the office sector and 34% exposed to the retail sector. 77% of office leases are expiring over the next 3 years and we are concern about falling reversionary rent achieved by the expiring office leases. Although expiring leases rent is lower than the passing average rent, however average rent for leases secured has peaked out in 2Q08 and has fallen 26% in 1Q09. Furthermore, Suntec REIT office portfolio could come under pressure from the completion of over 9.2 million sqf of office space in the core downtown area over the next five years. Given that our outlook is for a bottoming of office rent in 2010Q4, we would expect the gap between expiring leases and renewal leases to converge with a negative bias.
Suntec has no near term refinancing concern. It has successfully secure $825 million of term loan in April 2009. The current gearing is 35%. Although management has not indicated any acquisition plans, we believe that Suntec will build up its equity balance for two reasons; in anticipation of asset devaluation and to ready itself for any opportunities that arise for its next phase of growth. Currently Suntec owns approximately 57% of Suntec City Office Towers, it may resume its program to acquire strata office units not presently owned.
Valuation & recommendation. We revise our average rent and occupancy assumptions and reduce our DPU forecasts over FY09F-FY11F by 4%-9%. We maintain our Hold rating and raise our fair value from $0.69 to $0.94 mainly on lower WACC assumptions.
REITs – MS
Still the Best Way Forward
Maintain In-Line view: S-REITs remain our preferred sector exposure within the Singapore property space at least for 2009. S-REITs have not disappointed in terms of refinancing their debt. Indeed, they recapitalized their balance sheets 6 months ahead of our expectations. At least for 2009 and to a certain extent 2010, there is less risk of S-REITs cutting their dividend payout due to pressure from rising leverage. We remain comfortable that the recent fall in commitment rents will be marginally negative for 2009 earnings given that the brunt of the decline will be felt only in 2010 and 2011. A near-term positive catalyst for S-REITs is if the benchmark interest rate remains low after its recent decline.
We have a new sector top pick – A-REIT: We initiate coverage on A-REIT with an EW rating and price target of S$1.70, suggesting 11% upside from current levels. We like its 8.5-8.7% FY2010-11E dividend yield, the highest amongst its larger-cap peers, and find its recent underperformance unjustified. See our note, Steady as She Goes, published June 9, for details.
What’s new: We have revised our earnings forecasts by -1% to 39% for F2009-10E and raised our price targets by 17-112%. Given the improvement in liquidity in the equity market, investors may be willing to pay a premium above intrinsic value. Hence, for stocks that have recently recapitalized, we assign a 30% probability to our bull-case NAV and a 70% probability to our base-case NAV to calculate our price targets. We are maintaining our EW ratings on CapitaCommercial Trust, CapitaMall Trust, and CDLHT, and are downgrading Suntec REIT to Underweight given its 23% downside risk from current levels. We maintain our UW on ART.
Our investment philosophy for the S-REIT sector remains intact. Given that all the property segments – office, retail, industrial, and hospitality – are seeing oversupply for 2009-2010, the playing field is level. Moreover, all the S-REITs within our coverage are backed by strong parents and quality assets within their respective segments.
Office REITs – UOBKH
Office REITs – Outstripping Improvement In Fundamentals
The Federal Reserve extended the TALF programme to commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS) starting 1 Jun 09, hence the optimism and rally for S-REITs. However, we believe the rally in the past two weeks for office REITs has already factored in the improvement in fundamentals.
Office rentals still falling but at a slower pace. Due to the ongoing financial crisis, rentals for prime office space corrected 6.8% in 4Q08 and 30.0% in 1Q09 to S$10.50psf pm after hitting a peak of S$16.10psf in 3Q08. The Raffles Place micromarket registered the steepest fall of 17.9% in 4Q08 and 28.5% in 1Q09 to S$10.50psf pm. Our survey of office REITs indicates that office rentals have fallen by a slower 5-10% so far in 2Q09 due to an improvement in market sentiment.
Deals starting to flow. There are more transactions in the secondary market for strata office space recently. Capital value for Suntec City Office Towers has rebounded 10.8% to S$1,781psf ytd. Capital value for International Plaza has similarly rebounded by 9.2% to S$1,100psf. Unlike in previous recessions, there has been no distress or fire sale in the office market during the current recession. As such, cap rates have been stable.
Revaluation results in higher gearing. We remain concerned about the correction in office rentals due to new supply coming on stream. A total of 8.3m sf of office space will be completed from 2Q09 to 2013, representing 11.5% of total stock. A markdown in the value of investment properties on revaluation will result in higher gearing and potential rights issues.
Maintain OVERWEIGHT for REITs. Current yield spread is 3.61%, higher than the historical average of 2.97%. We expect yield spread to contract further as credit markets normalise. Refinancing risk has abated with the potential reopening of the CMBS market. We prefer switching to laggard retail and industrial REITs. BUY Frasers Centrepoint Trust and Ascendas REIT. Our only BUY for office REITs is K-REIT Asia.
Link : Table