Category: Suntec
Office REIT – UOBKH
A new record for office building
Foreign funds continue to grab office buildings. Commerz Real, a subsidiary of Germany-based Commerzbank, has bought 71 Robinson Road for a record S$743.8m or S$3,125psf. The building is owned by a partnership between Lehman Brothers and Kajima Overseas Asia. The site was acquired from Singtel for only S$163.4m in Oct 06 and is being redeveloped into a 15- storey Grade A office building with net lettable area of 238,000sf to be completed by mid-2009. Lehman Brothers and Kajima will provide Commerz Real with coupon of 4.5% during the period of construction.
This is a new record transaction price for office buildings, 7.7% higher than S$2,901psf for Hitachi Tower in Jan 08 and 20.2% higher then S$2,600psf for One George Street in Mar 08. We expect the news to create positive share price momentum for CCT, K-REIT and Suntec REIT.
Leasing momentum remains strong. According to Colliers International, rentals for Grade A prime office space in Raffles Place shot up from S$10.63psf pm in 1Q07 to S$16.64psf pm in 4Q07. Rentals for Raffles Place surged a further 5.3% qoq to S$17.52psf pm in 1Q08 as tenants chased after limited pockets of vacant space. There is strong demand from banks and financial institutions and supporting business services such as law and IT firms. Foreign financial institutions setting up operations in Singapore in 1Q08 includes Sun Hung Kai Fund Management, Man Investments, Swiss Life and MacQuarie Private Bank. Occupancy rate for Grade A office space in has further improved from 98.9% in 4Q07 to 99.1% in 1Q08.
Suntec – DBS
Making hay while the sun shines
Story: We believe Suntec’s depressed share price performance in recent months could be due to concerns about the refinancing of its bridging loan that is due Oct 2008 and is already priced in. Its current yields of 6.2- 6.7% are already higher than industry peers’ 5.3-5.8%. To put things into perspective, funding is unlikely to be a problem given its “Baa1” rating and low gearing, the
S$421m to be refinanced represents only 23% of total debt, and any incremental funding costs would have a marginal impact on total average interest cost and earnings.
Point: More importantly, investors should focus on the strong recurrent income stream from the group’s properties. Positive office rental reversions thanks to the sharp surge in rentals in the past 12 months should underpin earnings growth. There is further room for upward earnings revision when the group rejuvenates Park Mall, including developing two adjoining land parcels it bought recently. With gearing at 31%, funding these activities should not stretch its balance sheet significantly.
Relevance: The investment case for Suntec is its strong organic growth amid a positive office rental reversion cycle as well as attractive FY08F and FY09F yields of 6.2-6.7%. There is also room for earnings expansion as Park Mall has not been factored into our estimates. At the current price, valuations are undemanding vis-à-vis its sector peers. Our price target of S$1.98 is adjusted to reflect higher funding cost for the bridging loan, higher terminal cap rate of
4.5% (vs 4% previously), and dilution from CB conversion. Maintain Buy.
Suntec – OCBC
Solid defensive play
From here to uncertainty. The “REIT as growth” story was birthed by benevolent circumstances. Markets were strong, credit was easy, and the Singapore economy was flying. The property market was booming and the REITs became a surrogate for riding the wave. Suntec REIT (Suntec) itself saw a whopping cumulative S$2.1b in fair value gains on its property assets since its inception. Its share price hit S$2.13 last summer, a 213% gain over its 2004 IPO price. Circumstances are no longer so accommodating. Share prices of retail/office S-REITs have fallen more than 20% since July, reflecting the breakdown in the credit markets and uncertainty about future growth prospects.
Revising our expectations. We are factoring in this uncertainty into our expectations for Suntec. The deteriorating US economy will likely cause Singapore GDP growth to ease. We expect expansion in the financial sector, a key driver for office rentals, to also ease. The property market seems to have already hit a plateau. Our forecasts assume office rentals will peak by 2009. However, the downward correction should be marginal as the rally has been prematurely arrested.
Strongly positioned for DPU growth. What sets Suntec apart is that over 60% of its Park Mall and Suntec office assets are up for renewal in FY08-09. Currently rented at around S$5 psf per month, these assets offer a huge potential for rental upside. Suntec also has other avenues for improving yield via floor space additions to Park Mall and asset enhancements at its retail locations. Suntec City itself is finally set to realize its true potential as the Marina area blossoms with the completion of the Circle Line and the Integrated Resorts in 2010.
Solid defensive play. The de-rating of S-REITs has given investors another opportunity to take a fresh look at Suntec as a defensive vehicle offering stable cash flows and high yields. It is trading at a 34% discount to its 1Q NAV of S$2.2. There is some concern over the expiry of the two bridge loans in 2009 relating to its One Raffles Quay acquisition, which we think is overdone. We estimate Suntec’s DPU at about 9 S cents in FY08, yielding more than 6% or 400bps over 2-yr Singapore government bond. Maintain BUY at fair value S$1.71.
Suntec – Merrill Lynch
Suntec REIT has completed the issue of convertible bonds to the value of S$250mn to refinance upcoming debt. The bonds will bear an interest rate of 3.25% and a yield to maturity of 4.25%. The bonds are due for expiry in 2013 with a conversion price of S$1.968/share. The proceeds will be used to pay down the S$180mn bridging loan due in April 08 while the balance is intended to be used towards the bridging loan due in Oct 08.
Reduction in fair value estimate
Our FY08 and FY09 net earnings estimates have been reduced (<1%) to account for the marginally increased interest expense (average financing cost at Dec 07 3.13%). We have reduced our DCF derived fair value estimate from S$1.67 to S$1.56 due to dilution when the bonds are converted in 2013.
Debt refinancing in 2008
In addition to the debt refinanced through the convertible bond issuance, Suntec has $490mn of debt due to mature in Oct 08. Of this S$420mn will need to be refinanced (S$70mn paid down from convertible proceeds). Suntec also has short term debts of S$75mn which will need to be refinanced in 2008.
Maintain Neutral
Valuations for the stock remain undemanding however we remain cautious on REITs with sizable near term debt expiry. With no visible catalyst and possible headwinds due to debt renewal we maintain our Neutral rating. Our preferred exposure to the Singapore office market remains CapitaCommercial Trust (CMIAF; B-1-7; S$1.98).
SREIT – JPM
JPM Tips 3 S-REITS To Short Based On “Crash Tests”
JPMorgan tips three Singapore REITS, or S-REITs, to own based on “crash-test” scenarios. “The S-REITs to own have sustainable income streams, relatively conservative asset values and gearing levels at the lower end of the risk spectrum. General risk aversion toward the sector as well as the debt refinancing overhang has created the most obvious valuation anomalies when risk is taken into account,” analysts Christopher Gee and Joy Wang say in report. Expects the market-weighted long portfolio to post 31% total return through end-2008. Says likes A-REIT (A17U.SG) with target price of S$2.93, CapitaMall Trust (C38U.SG) with target price of S$3.67, CapitaCommercial Trust (C61U.SG) with target price of S$2.27; all three rated Overweight. At Thursday’s close, A-REIT ended down 3.9% at S$1.98, CapitaMall +0.3% at S$3.11, CapitaCommercial down 3.6% at S$1.90.
JPM Cuts K-REIT Tgt To S$1.34; Keeps Underweight
JPMorgan cuts K-REIT (K71U.SG) target price to S$1.34 from S$1.52 on prospect of more substantial dilution to equity holders resulting from REIT’s proposed rights issue. Keeps at Underweight. “The key upside risks to our price target for K-REIT could come from an unexpected improvement in the outlook for office property in Singapore, or confidence being restored in real estate capital markets, thus allowing K-REIT to get out of the vicious cycle it is in currently.”
JPM Downgrades CDL Hospitality To Underweight
JPMorgan downgrades CDL Hospitality Trust to Underweight from Overweight, cuts target price to S$1.51 from S$2.55. Cuts follow house running worst-case scenario through valuation models for all S-REITs under coverage. Says S-REITs with highest lease expiries in 2008-09 are most exposed to sudden deterioration in demand conditions if either rental rates or occupancy levels were to drop unexpectedly. Adds, hospitality-oriented S-REITs, such as CDL Hospitality Trust, are most acutely affected in this test.